give discipline

USAGE SUMMARY

The part of the sentence 'give discipline' is not correct or usable in written English.
You would need to use the phrase 'impose discipline' instead. For example, "The teacher imposed discipline in the classroom by assigning extra homework to students who were disruptive."

⚠ May contain grammatical issues

News & Media

Science

Wiki

Human-verified examples from authoritative sources

Exact Expressions

2 human-written examples

Wolves are able to give discipline and structure to the pups without punishment.

The New York Times - Science

"We like to give discipline," he says firmly.

Vice

Human-verified similar examples from authoritative sources

Similar Expressions

58 human-written examples

Ms. Marcus, his mother added, has given "discipline" to her son's life.

The New York Times

The subjects taking part of the program of a given degree focus on achieving knowledge in a given discipline.

Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences

Given discipline, patience — and a measure of courage — it may be the only means of reaching certain patients.

The New York Times - Books

A new essay was published each week, paired with stories from readers who work within the given discipline about their own cultural epiphanies.

The New York Times

A new essay will arrive each week, paired with stories from readers who work within the given discipline about their own cultural epiphanies.

The New York Times - Arts

Often the practitioners of a given discipline are in the best position to teach students how to write for that discipline.

University of California, Berkeley

If we are to apply progressive ideals appropriately to a given discipline, we need to equip ourselves with a good understanding of what thinking in that discipline is like.

The New York Times

Put simply, the level of expectation, in terms of critical thinking and analysis within any given discipline, is significantly lower at the most prestigious of the US institutions than at their UK counterparts.

The Guardian

Mr. Pittman, the founder of the MTV cable network, is widely credited with giving discipline to the on-line service, improving its customer service and focusing it more on the bottom line.

The New York Times

Expert writing Tips

Best practice

Instead of using "give discipline", consider stronger verbs like "instill", "impart", or "enforce" to convey the action of establishing discipline. For example, "instill discipline through consistent expectations" is more effective.

Common error

Avoid using "give" with abstract nouns like "discipline". While seemingly straightforward, it often sounds vague. Replace it with a verb that more precisely describes how discipline is imparted, such as "establish", "foster", or "promote".

Linguistic Context

The phrase "give discipline" functions as a verb phrase where "give" acts as a transitive verb and "discipline" as its direct object. However, Ludwig AI indicates it's not correct in written English. The intended function is to describe the act of providing or imparting discipline, although better alternatives exist.

Expression frequency: Rare

Frequent in

News & Media

33%

Science

33%

Wiki

33%

Less common in

Formal & Business

0%

Academia

0%

Encyclopedias

0%

Ludwig's WRAP-UP

In summary, while the phrase "give discipline" may appear in various contexts, Ludwig AI suggests it's not the most accurate or preferred way to express the concept of imparting discipline. More effective alternatives like "instill discipline", "impart discipline", or "enforce discipline" offer greater clarity and precision. Given its grammatical weakness and the availability of stronger alternatives, it's advisable to use "give discipline" with caution, particularly in formal writing. As Ludwig pointed out, the phrase is not the best choice and better expressions are available.

More alternative expressions

Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:

instill discipline

Focuses on implanting discipline as a quality.

impart discipline

Highlights the act of transmitting discipline.

provide structure

Emphasizes establishing a framework for discipline.

enforce rules

Focuses on making sure the rules are followed, a component of discipline.

impose order

Stresses establishing a structured and controlled environment.

set boundaries

Highlights the creation of limits, which are important for discipline.

teach self-control

Focuses on educating about managing one's own actions.

develop character

Addresses the long-term cultivation of disciplined behavior.

mold behavior

Indicates shaping actions towards discipline.

cultivate responsibility

Emphasizes fostering a sense of duty.

FAQs

Is "give discipline" grammatically correct?

While sometimes used, the phrase "give discipline" is not considered standard English. It's better to use more precise verbs like "instill discipline" or "enforce discipline".

What can I say instead of "give discipline"?

You can use alternatives like "impart discipline", "provide structure", or "foster responsibility" depending on the specific context.

How can I use "discipline" in a sentence more effectively?

Instead of focusing on "giving" discipline, emphasize the actions that establish it. For instance, say "The coach "enforces discipline" through rigorous training" rather than "The coach "gives discipline"".

What's the difference between "give discipline" and "instill discipline"?

"Give discipline" is vague and less common. "Instill discipline" implies a more deliberate and impactful process of embedding discipline as a quality within someone.