The mean reduction of migraine frequency, intensity and duration from baseline to follow-up were 42, 13, and 36% in CSMT group, and 17, 5, and 21% in the control group (data calculated by the reviewers based on figures from the paper).
The descriptions are complex and the paper would be clearer if the figures from the original papers were included so that it was evident what the population trends were that were being discussed.
It raised an endlessly fascinating question: what was the link between immune-response genes and schizophrenia?" Lieberman pulled out a figure from the paper to illustrate the strength of the association.
The following figure from the paper is as clear as ice – while there was a short-term increase from 2012 to 2013, the Arctic has lost more than half its sea ice over the past three decades.
Given these concerns, we recommend removing these results and the corresponding figure from the paper as it currently does not significantly strengthen the manuscript.
For references that did not provide HRs, we referred to the methods described by Tierney et al. [ 20] to obtain the HRs using the data and figures from the original papers [ 19, 21- 23].
Those two papers are now under close scrutiny after NEJM editors found that two figures from the first paper are duplicates, one a magnified version of the other.
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.7554/eLife.08127.004 To illustrate that we can correctly recapitulate the analysis undertaken in (Bushdid et al., 2014), Figure 2 shows our reproduction (using raw supplementary data from [ Bushdid et al., 2014]) of two critical figures from that paper (Bushdid et al., 2014), from which its main conclusion was drawn.
That figure comes from the paper's own deputy chief executive Ben Hughes as revealed at the MediaGuardian Changing Advertising Summit (via paidContent).
Figure 2, from the paper of Johnson and Flagler (1951), vividly shows this effect.
