The arc of any genre is going to be contended, and the length of this particular arc won't be agreed upon without a fair amount of dissent (and neither resolution nor consensus is necessary).
It would have to give dissent a fair shake.
In a string of recent appraisal cases, the Court of Chancery held that in certain circumstances, the fair value of the dissenting stockholders' shares was best determined by the per-share merger price less any merger-related synergies rather than an analytical valuation method such as discounted cash flows.
In a case such as this one, in which an impaired class does not vote to accept the plan, the plan proponent must also show that the plan meets the additional requirements of § 1129(b), including the requirements that the plan does not unfairly discriminate against dissenting classes and the treatment of the dissenting classes is fair and equitable.
Americans once had a shared commitment to the traditional liberal democratic values: individual liberties, human rights, tolerance of dissent, free and fair elections, a free press, due process and separation of powers.
Given a judicial process that is stacked against drug-offenders and the government's general animosity toward political dissent, it's fair to wonder if Iran uses drug crimes to trump up charges against, and even execute, opposition figures.
Amazingly, Sky News is much more open to dissent and gives much fairer representation to anti-war voices than the BBC.
But after reading the dissent, I thought it was fair to make the point about federalism.
"It was decided to move forward on the basis of consensus, but it's fair to say there wasn't a dissenting voice," said the spokesman.
For no good reason, the Court deprives the State of Michigan of its right to have one fair opportunity to convict petitioner, and I therefore respectfully dissent.
In dissent, Justice David H. Souter warned that "it seems fair to ask whether the step taken by the court today does anything but portend a return to the untenable jurisprudence from which the court extricated itself almost 60 years ago".
