Used and loved by millions
Since I tried Ludwig back in 2017, I have been constantly using it in both editing and translation. Ever since, I suggest it to my translators at ProSciEditing.

Justyna Jupowicz-Kozak
CEO of Professional Science Editing for Scientists @ prosciediting.com
earlier providing
Grammar usage guide and real-world examplesUSAGE SUMMARY
The phrase "earlier providing" is not correct in standard written English.
It may be intended to refer to something that was provided previously, but it lacks clarity and proper grammatical structure. Example: "In the report, we discussed the findings earlier providing insights into the project's progress."
⚠ May contain grammatical issues
Science
News & Media
Alternative expressions(1)
Table of contents
Usage summary
Human-verified examples
Expert writing tips
Linguistic context
Ludwig's wrap-up
Alternative expressions
FAQs
Human-verified examples from authoritative sources
Exact Expressions
4 human-written examples
We developed a plugin to Bioclipse that searches the Internet for information about a molecule, initiated with the InChI and a web service we developed earlier, providing Universal Resource Identifiers for molecules, available at http://rdf.openmolecules.net/[23].net/[23]
Science
In 2012 a 92-year-old woman, who had been living with severe Alzheimer's in a nursing home, was found to have fifty-seven maggots writhing inside of her, an enlarged ear canal from a surgery decades earlier providing a cozy home.
News & Media
There will continue to be the early-access advantage in fast turnaround fields: It is not that making findings accessible earlier merely gets them their citation "quota" earlier; providing OA earlier significantly increases that quota, probably by both accelerating and broadening the uptake of the findings in further research [33].
Science
Figure 5 shows a clear co-localization of O2·− with lignified cellulose as early as 3 h from transfer to 23 °C, but not earlier, providing further evidence that these are developing pro-vascular tissues.
Science
Human-verified similar examples from authoritative sources
Similar Expressions
54 human-written examples
Certainly, his earlier provide plenty of evidence of irrationality.
News & Media
"Our peak lambing season is March to May, but we can produce lambs earlier provided we get sufficient notice.
News & Media
Although it's awkwardly introduced, an unpublished novel written decades earlier provides the parallel plot about another brother and sister who share a home.
News & Media
aThis value is much lower than the IEA value earlier provided for the rural-urban shares.
The CCF presented earlier provides a simple solution to these shortcomings.
Science
The A3 Architecture Overviews introduced earlier provide a powerful communication medium in systems engineering and architecting.
Science
The experimental results can quantitatively be predicted by a model published earlier, provided the phase dimensions are measured separately.
Science
Expert writing Tips
Best practice
When describing past actions, use clear and grammatically correct phrases such as "previously providing" or "having provided earlier" to avoid ambiguity.
Common error
Be cautious of using "earlier providing" as it may sound awkward. Instead, use a clearer phrasing like "previously provided" or "had provided earlier" to ensure readability and grammatical accuracy.
Source & Trust
82%
Authority and reliability
2.8/5
Expert rating
Real-world application tested
Linguistic Context
The phrase "earlier providing" functions as a modifier, attempting to specify a temporal relationship, but the structure is not grammatically standard. As Ludwig AI points out, it's better to use more specific and grammatically correct alternatives.
Frequent in
Science
75%
News & Media
25%
Formal & Business
0%
Less common in
Encyclopedias
0%
Wiki
0%
Social Media
0%
Ludwig's WRAP-UP
The phrase "earlier providing" is not considered grammatically correct in standard English. Ludwig AI indicates that the phrasing is awkward and lacks clarity. While the intended meaning is to refer to something provided previously, it's better to use alternatives such as "previously providing", "having provided earlier", or other similar constructions. The phrase appears rarely, mostly in science and news contexts, but should be avoided in formal writing to ensure clarity and grammatical accuracy.
More alternative expressions(6)
Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:
previously providing
Replaces "earlier" with "previously" to emphasize the time aspect of the action.
already providing
Uses "already" instead of "earlier" to denote that the action of providing was completed before.
initially providing
Specifies that the act of providing occurred at the beginning or outset.
before providing
Emphasizes the sequence of events, with the act of providing coming after a specific time.
having provided earlier
Uses a perfect participle to indicate a completed action of providing before a certain point.
which provided earlier
Adds a relative clause to clarify the action of providing in relation to something previously mentioned.
that provided earlier
Specifies the subject or thing that provided something at a previous time.
previously offered
Replaces "providing" with "offered" and "earlier" with "previously" to provide a different word choice for the same meaning.
formerly providing
Emphasizes the action of providing occurred at some time in the past but not anymore.
supplying previously
Swaps out "providing" with "supplying" and relocates "previously" for varied word order.
FAQs
How can I rephrase "earlier providing" to sound more natural?
Instead of "earlier providing", consider using phrases like "previously providing", "already providing", or "initially providing" depending on the context.
What is a grammatically correct alternative to "earlier providing"?
A grammatically correct alternative would be using the past perfect construction such as "having provided earlier" or simply rephrasing with "previously provided".
Is "earlier providing" considered formal or informal language?
"Earlier providing" is not considered standard English and should be avoided in both formal and informal writing. Opt for clearer alternatives like "previously provided".
How does "earlier providing" differ from "previously providing"?
"Previously providing" is a more standard and grammatically sound way to express the idea of something being provided at an earlier time, compared to the less common and somewhat awkward phrasing of "earlier providing".
Editing plus AI, all in one place.
Stop switching between tools. Your AI writing partner for everything—polishing proposals, crafting emails, finding the right tone.
Table of contents
Usage summary
Human-verified examples
Expert writing tips
Linguistic context
Ludwig's wrap-up
Alternative expressions
FAQs
Source & Trust
82%
Authority and reliability
2.8/5
Expert rating
Real-world application tested