Sentence examples for determining rule from inspiring English sources

But the opponents saw in it a repudiation of the Bible as the determining rule of practice.

For instance, if having an intentional state with a certain content is itself a matter of being guided by a content determining rule, then another intentional state is required for having the first one, and so on ad infinitum.

Even if guidance normativism would ultimately not be able to sustain a substantive difference between following a content determining rule and mere accordance with it, one might still hold on to the claim that there are contentful intentional states only if the rules of rationality are in force for them.

What, then, does it mean for a meaning determining rule R to be in force for a speaker S's use of an expression e (at a time t)?[28] Broadly, there are three main options for the MD normativist (see section 1.2 above).

They also argue that if a meaning determining rule R for an expression e requires e to be used correctly, there is no room for such rules in the explanation of speech acts: If a speaker wants to say that p, a rule requiring them to use e correctly not only is of no help, there is no "slot" in the practical syllogism into which it would coherently fit (Glüer & Pagin 1999, 223f).

An analogous suggestion could be made for guidance by meaning determining rules or norms.

It might be more promising to allow meaning determining rules to have prescriptive force.

When combined with MD normativism, communitarianism usually construes meaning determining rules as conventions adopted by whole speech communities.

Meaning determining rules clearly would be constitutive rules (see section 1.2 above): Meaningful use of linguistic expressions is metaphysically impossible without such rules.

The crucial question thus is what the distinction between rule guided behavior and merely regular behavior amounts to when it comes to meaning determining rules.

Moreover, meaning determining rules (usually) are supposed to determine not only that an expression has meaning, but also which meaning it has.