detailed comments

USAGE SUMMARY

The phrase "detailed comments" is a perfectly acceptable phrase in written English.
You might use the phrase when you are asking someone to give you more detailed feedback than simply saying something is "good" or "bad". For example, you might say, "Can you please give me some detailed comments about the report I submitted?".

✓ Grammatically correct

Science

News & Media

Human-verified examples from authoritative sources

Exact Expressions

60 human-written examples

I wrote very detailed comments.

The New York Times

(His more detailed comments are posted here).

The New York Times

We appreciate your feedback, more detailed comments can be submitted using this form.

The Guardian

Boeing said it would make more detailed comments when it filed the protest.

The New York Times

"It would not be appropriate to make further detailed comments on matters that are subject to ongoing operations".

The Guardian

On the recording she gives Ms. Hebert detailed comments, including astute explanations of ornamentation in the Bellini style.

The New York Times - Arts

We appreciate detailed comments of both reviewers.

Earth, Planets and Space

Instructive discussions and detailed comments by Shan de Silva and unknown reviewer significantly improve this paper.

Earth, Planets and Space

The question attracted significant discussion, with some users sending us long and detailed comments.

Human-centric Computing and Information Sciences

We appreciate the detailed comments from Dr. Fujiya and an anonymous reviewer.

Earth, Planets and Space

We thank the Editor and two Reviewers for the detailed comments and suggestions given during the manuscript review process.

Geoscience Letters

Expert writing Tips

Best practice

Provide context or guidelines to ensure that reviewers understand the scope and objectives of your work before they provide "detailed comments".

Common error

Avoid asking for "detailed comments" without specifying what aspects need scrutiny. Broad requests can lead to unfocused and less helpful feedback. Instead, guide reviewers with specific questions or areas of concern.

Linguistic Context

The phrase "detailed comments" functions as a noun phrase where "detailed" modifies the noun "comments". This phrase typically describes the nature of feedback provided, emphasizing its thoroughness and specificity. Ludwig AI confirms that this phrase is commonly used across various contexts.

Expression frequency: Very common

Frequent in

Science

42%

News & Media

28%

Wiki

5%

Less common in

Encyclopedias

2%

Formal & Business

1%

Reference

0%

Ludwig's WRAP-UP

In summary, the phrase "detailed comments" is a common and grammatically sound expression used to describe feedback that is thorough and specific. As highlighted by Ludwig, it appears frequently in academic, scientific, and news-related contexts, indicating its versatility and broad applicability. When seeking or providing feedback, specifying the need for "detailed comments" sets an expectation for in-depth analysis and constructive criticism. To maximize the effectiveness of such feedback, it's crucial to provide clear guidelines and context to reviewers, ensuring that their insights are both relevant and valuable.

More alternative expressions

Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:

comprehensive feedback

Emphasizes the thoroughness and completeness of the feedback provided.

thorough remarks

Highlights the depth and careful consideration behind the remarks.

extensive notes

Focuses on the breadth and scope of the notes provided as feedback.

in-depth critique

Stresses the analytical and probing nature of the critical assessment.

elaborate review

Indicates a detailed and painstaking examination.

minute observations

Suggests a focus on very small or precise points.

specific suggestions

Emphasizes the clarity and precision of the suggestions.

thorough analysis

Indicates a comprehensive investigation.

complete evaluation

Highlights the exhaustive nature of the assessment.

precise feedback

Emphasizes accuracy and exactness in the feedback given.

FAQs

How can I ask for "detailed comments" effectively?

To get the most useful "detailed comments", provide clear instructions, specify the areas you want feedback on, and explain the purpose of your work. This helps reviewers provide targeted and relevant insights.

What are some synonyms for "detailed comments"?

Alternatives include "comprehensive feedback", "thorough remarks", and "extensive notes". The best choice depends on the specific context and the type of feedback being given.

How do "detailed comments" differ from general comments?

"Detailed comments" provide specific, in-depth feedback, often including examples and justifications. General comments are broader and may lack the depth and specificity needed for effective revision.

In what situations are "detailed comments" most valuable?

"Detailed comments" are crucial when refining complex documents, research papers, or creative works. They help identify weaknesses, improve clarity, and ensure accuracy and coherence.