The principle of charity, so understood, would not favor liberal interpretations over demanding interpretations.
Given the availability of both liberal and demanding interpretations, the principle of charity would evidently favor the former.
The idea behind M2 is that, since the liberal interpretations are otherwise on a par with the demanding interpretations, charity wins out and 'there are statues' is true.
The demanding interpretations on which D1 comes out false do better than the liberal interpretations on this score, since they can make all of D2 through D4 come out true.
One who accepts this sort of account may maintain that the demanding interpretations, although less charitable, nevertheless assign more natural contents to English sentences than the liberal interpretations, for instance, by assigning a more natural meaning to the quantifiers.
As description itself demands interpretation, it might be more useful to see aggregative and interpretive approaches as two poles on a continuum rather than two distinct approaches.
It demanded interpretation, completion, creation.
All movies demand interpretation, but Mr. Carax doesn't seem interested in your solving his puzzle, which allows you to solve it as you like.
Since then this drama about an "innocent fool" who gains knowledge in the act of resisting temptation and restores the power of the knights of the Holy Grail has demanded interpretation.
They demand interpretation.
