Sentence examples for competent reviewer from inspiring English sources

A recent paper in Science reported some very disturbing results: a manuscript with major flaws that any competent reviewer should notice was accepted by the majority of journals to which it was submitted, without major criticisms.

This kind of collegial consultation sometimes takes time, however, as the most competent reviewers usually are the busiest.

We appreciate very much the competent review, suggestions and comments by two reviewers and the associate editor which all improved the manuscript considerably.

Here journal editors are dependent on reviewers competent in both the relevant substantive theory and SEM's statistical methodology.

I will leave the bioenergetics to reviewers more competent in that area, and comment or expand on just a few of the Nick Lane's general evolutionary propositions.

Furthermore, 39.6% (95% CI: 37.0% - 42.3%) agreed that reviewers are competent and 19%9595% CI: 16.9% - 21.1%) agreed that the current system is free from interference.

One might think (a point suggested by a reviewer) that surely competent practitioners make this distinction as a matter of course?

We do not know how many reviewers read any individual paper and the extent they actually read the whole paper and were more competent to judge than the field specific peer reviewers who initially reviewed the article.

We also show our gratitude to the reviewers for their dedication, expertise, and competent feedback.

In response to the reviewers' recommendations, the TCDC, as the competent authority for these matters, are carrying out policy analysis of current entry screening procedures, as well as the vector surveillance/control on aircrafts (Table 1).

Allmusic reviewer William Ruhlmann stated the album is "a competent example of its genre" awarding the album three and a half stars.