comments on the paper

USAGE SUMMARY

The phrase "comments on the paper" is correct and usable in written English.
It can be used when referring to feedback or observations made regarding a specific academic or written work. Example: "The professor provided insightful comments on the paper, highlighting areas for improvement."

✓ Grammatically correct

Science

News & Media

Human-verified examples from authoritative sources

Exact Expressions

60 human-written examples

[Relevant UPDATE below — link to comments on the paper by Senator Inhofe's staff.] May 5 RealClimate will be weighing in, but please do feel free to post some or all of my own comments.

The New York Times

We would like to thank reviewers (Drs. Brad Aagaard, Erol Kalkan, and others) for their insightful comments on the paper.

Earth, Planets and Space

In the same issue of Science, pages 400 401, News&Analyses section Michael Balter comments on the paper in "Ancient Migrants Brought Farming Way of Life to Europe".

Evolution: Education and Outreach

This report is a response to the comments on the paper prepared by D. Kumlutas et al. [Int. J. Refrigeration 35 (2012) 1678 1689].

International Journal of Refrigeration

This note makes some remarks and comments on the paper [1] concerning a reduced-complexity controller design for an active suspension benchmark [6].

European Journal of Control

In the present paper a few comments on the paper "Fracture study of the composite using essential work of fracture method: PP-SEBS-g-MA/E1 clay" Materials and Design 53 (2014) 741 748, have been discussed.

Materials & Design

In this note, in response to the previous note by Zinoviev and Bies [Author's Reply to: F. Farassat, Comments on the paper by Zinoviev and Bies "On acoustic radiation by a rigid object in a fluid flow", Journal of Sound and Vibration 281 (2005) 1224 1237], the present authors briefly discuss the assumptions used in the acoustic analogy and its intended applications.

Journal of Sound and Vibration

Some comments on the paper [Yin C, Zhong S-M, Chen W-F. Design of sliding mode controller for a class of fractional-order chaotic systems. Commun Nonlinear Sci Numer Simulat 17 (2012) 356 366] are pointed out in this note.

Communications in Nonlinear Science and Numerical Simulation

The authors would like to thank Ph. Küpfer, J. Grant and N. Alvarez for their support and constructive comments on the paper.

Plosone

We would like to express our gratitude to Tom Wandless's lab for iRap, to Dr. Peter Devreotes for proposing the PTX experiments, and to Drs. Hahn, Galic and Salmeen in the Meyer's lab for critical comments on the paper.

Plosone

The authors thank Andrew Pomiankowski and two anonymous reviewers for comments on the paper, and Rosli Hashim and the staff at the Gombak Valley Field Research Centre, University of Malaya, Kuala Lumpur for logistical support.

Plosone

Expert writing Tips

Best practice

When seeking "comments on the paper", be specific about the areas where feedback is most needed to ensure reviewers focus their efforts effectively.

Common error

Avoid asking for general "comments on the paper" without specifying what kind of feedback you're looking for. This can lead to unfocused and less helpful reviews. Instead, ask specific questions about clarity, methodology, or argumentation.

Linguistic Context

The phrase "comments on the paper" functions as a noun phrase, typically serving as the object of a verb (e.g., provide, receive, give). It refers to feedback or remarks related to a written document, as Ludwig AI confirms.

Expression frequency: Very common

Frequent in

Science

75%

News & Media

15%

Formal & Business

10%

Less common in

Wiki

0%

Encyclopedias

0%

Reference

0%

Ludwig's WRAP-UP

In summary, the phrase "comments on the paper" is a grammatically sound and frequently used noun phrase. It's primarily used in formal and scientific contexts to refer to feedback or remarks on a written document. According to Ludwig AI, the phrase is correct and usable. Common alternatives include "feedback regarding the paper" and "critique of the paper". To use the phrase effectively, be specific in your requests for feedback. Be mindful that overly broad requests may result in less helpful reviews. Ensure you acknowledge and consider the received feedback thoughtfully. Ludwig's analysis highlights that while grammatically straightforward, contextual awareness is crucial for its effective usage in academic and professional settings.

More alternative expressions

Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:

feedback regarding the paper

Replaces "comments" with "feedback" to emphasize the evaluative nature of the input.

critique of the paper

Substitutes "comments" with "critique" to suggest a more in-depth analysis.

analysis of the paper

Focuses on the analytical aspect of the feedback provided.

observations about the paper

Uses "observations" to denote a more general set of remarks.

input on the paper

Replaces "comments" with "input" to suggest a contribution to the document's improvement.

remarks concerning the paper

Employs "remarks" as a formal synonym for "comments".

assessment of the paper

Indicates an evaluation or judgment of the paper's quality.

evaluation of the paper

Highlights the act of assessing the value and merit of the paper.

suggestions for the paper

Focuses on offering ideas to improve the paper's content or structure.

thoughts on the paper

Offers a broader, more informal alternative to "comments".

FAQs

How can I ask for "comments on the paper" effectively?

To get the most helpful feedback, be specific. Instead of asking for general "comments on the paper", try "Could you provide feedback on the methodology section?" or "I'd appreciate your comments on the clarity of the introduction."

What are some alternatives to "comments on the paper"?

You can use alternatives like "feedback regarding the paper", "critique of the paper", or "analysis of the paper" depending on the context.

What's the difference between "comments on the paper" and "peer review of the paper"?

"Comments on the paper" typically refer to informal feedback from colleagues or advisors, while "peer review of the paper" implies a formal evaluation process by experts in the field, often for publication purposes.

How do I respond to "comments on the paper" I've received?

Acknowledge the feedback, consider each point carefully, and revise your paper accordingly. If you disagree with a comment, prepare a reasoned explanation for your decision. Thank the reviewers for their time and effort.