commented with

USAGE SUMMARY

"commented with" is a correct and usable phrase in written English.
It is usually used in the context of adding a thought or opinion to a conversation or discussion. For example: "The student was asked her opinion on the topic and she commented with intelligence and clarity."

✓ Grammatically correct

News & Media

Science

Wiki

Human-verified examples from authoritative sources

Exact Expressions

58 human-written examples

"He told me it would take a couple of weeks," Dr. Gregorian commented, with a laugh.

The New York Times

At the weekend she commented: "With airbrushing and digital manipulation, fashion can project an unobtainable image that's dangerously unhealthy.

The Guardian - Opinion

Visitors to New York invariably commented with horror on interracial nature of the goings-on in these places.

The New York Times

While she enjoyed the story and the music, she commented with a tad of disappointment: "The movie wasn't what I expected.

The New York Times

Friends and readers have commented, with concern, that rest days are necessary for your body to recover and train more effectively.

The Guardian - Lifestyle

Martin Beck of Oxford Economics commented: "With growth in the third quarter likely to be wholly reliant on services, the goal of a better-balanced economy looks an ever-more-distant prospect".

The Guardian - Business

He once remarked that people were always telling him what a good dramaturg he was - as if to say, he commented with wry self-irony, that as a director he left something to be desired.

The Guardian

Started months ago by Julian de Guzman, plenty of former TFC players commented, with varying degrees of bitterness/immaturity and were joined by two players still at the club in Doneil Henry and academy kid Jordan Hamilton.

The Guardian - Sport

When I called Professor Galbraith to reminisce about the Byrnes speech, he commented with his famous light touch, "I've never listened to a speech with a greater sense of approval".

The New York Times

No one quite believed Ms. Tcherkassky, a leading ballerina with the company and Mr. Orr's wife, when she commented with her characteristic gentleness that now she could have a garden.

The New York Times

A young man, upon attending one of his concerts, commented with a note of sourness (perhaps in appraisal of his own romantic prospects) that "to Chinese women he's the picture-perfect prince riding up on a white horse".

The New Yorker

Expert writing Tips

Best practice

Use "commented with" to clearly indicate that someone is adding their thoughts or opinions to a conversation or discussion. Ensure the context aligns with the nature of the comment (e.g., "commented with enthusiasm" or "commented with concern").

Common error

Avoid substituting "with" for other prepositions like "on" or "about" when using "commented". "Commented on" is used when referring to the topic of the comment. Make sure the phrase is used to indicate how the comment was delivered.

Linguistic Context

The phrase "commented with" functions as a verb phrase, indicating an action (commenting) along with a descriptor of how that action was performed. As Ludwig AI confirms, this usage is grammatically correct and common. The "with" introduces additional context, often describing a feeling, tone, or characteristic.

Expression frequency: Very common

Frequent in

News & Media

58%

Science

25%

Wiki

5%

Less common in

Formal & Business

5%

Encyclopedias

0%

Reference

0%

Ludwig's WRAP-UP

In summary, "commented with" is a grammatically sound and versatile phrase used to describe the manner in which someone makes a comment. Ludwig AI confirms its grammatical correctness and wide applicability. While versatile, it's important to use it appropriately by focusing on describing how the comment was delivered rather than what the comment was about, as misuse can lead to prepositional errors. As demonstrated by Ludwig's examples, this phrase is frequently found in News & Media, Science, and Wiki sources, showcasing its prevalence across diverse writing contexts.

More alternative expressions

Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:

remarked with

Similar to "commented with", but emphasizes a brief and often casual statement.

stated with

Implies a more formal and deliberate expression of an opinion or fact.

observed with

Suggests a comment based on careful observation or consideration.

added with

Indicates a comment that is supplementary to a previous statement.

responded with

Highlights the act of replying to a question or remark with a comment.

noted with

Similar to "observed with", but slightly less formal and emphasizes awareness.

mentioned with

Indicates a brief and often incidental reference to something in the comment.

expressed with

Suggests a clear and direct communication of thoughts or feelings with the comment.

related with

Refers to telling a story or giving an account with the comment.

shared with

Indicates the act of making information known to others with the comment.

FAQs

How can I use "commented with" in a sentence?

You can use "commented with" to show the manner in which someone made a remark, such as "She "commented with enthusiasm"" or "He "commented with disappointment"".

What are some alternatives to "commented with"?

Alternatives include "remarked with", "stated with", or "observed with", depending on the specific nuance you want to convey.

Is it more appropriate to use "commented with" or "commented on"?

"Commented with" emphasizes the manner of commenting, whereas "commented on" focuses on the subject of the comment. Use "commented with" to describe how someone commented, and "commented on" to describe what they commented about.

Can "commented with" be used in formal writing?

Yes, "commented with" is suitable for both formal and informal writing, as long as it accurately reflects the manner in which the comment was made. More formal alternatives, such as "stated with", might be preferable in highly formal contexts.