commented over the

USAGE SUMMARY

The phrase "commented over the" is not correct in standard written English.
It is typically used incorrectly when trying to indicate that someone has made a comment about something. Example: "She commented over the recent changes in the policy during the meeting."

⚠ May contain grammatical issues

News & Media

Science

Wiki

Human-verified examples from authoritative sources

Exact Expressions

10 human-written examples

The first question asked whether anyone had seriously commented over the past 30 days that the student was "too fat".

BMC Public Health

Students responded if family members, peers and professionals had seriously commented over the past 30 days that they were "too fat" or "too thin" in two separate questions.

BMC Public Health

Mr. Abbas commented over the weekend on the reports of a possible Israeli offer.

The New York Times

President Obasanjo finally commented over the weekend, seeming to suggest on state television that the soldiers had acted in self-defense.

The New York Times

On behalf of the other bloggers – Paul MacInnes, Zoe Williams, Richard Vine and myself – I'd like to thank everyone who's commented over the past six or so years.

The Guardian - TV & Radio

As the New York Post's Michael Goodwin, a Trump supporter, commented over the weekend, the President is "trapped with no protection or escape from Mueller".

The New Yorker

Human-verified similar examples from authoritative sources

Similar Expressions

46 human-written examples

Thanks for keeping me company, emailing in and commenting over the past two days.

The Guardian - Sport

I registered about three years ago, but have only really been commenting over the past year.

The Guardian - Opinion

A spokesman for Mossack Fonseca declined to comment over the Nahmad case.

The Guardian

Mr Brown, the force and the Police Federation of England and Wales all declined to comment over the dispute.

Independent

"If Taobao were paralyzed, how could Alibaba reform and develop?" Yahoo, which is based in Sunnyvale, Calif., declined to comment over the weekend.

The New York Times - Tech

Expert writing Tips

Best practice

Use "commented on" instead of "commented over the" to ensure grammatical correctness. For example, say "He commented on the new policy" instead of "He commented over the new policy".

Common error

Avoid using "over" when "on" is grammatically correct. "Commented over" is not a standard English construction. Instead, use "commented on" to maintain clarity and credibility in your writing.

Linguistic Context

The phrase "commented over the" is typically used to express that someone has made a comment or observation regarding a particular subject or event. However, it is considered grammatically incorrect in standard English. As Ludwig AI suggests, the more appropriate phrasing is "commented on".

Expression frequency: Uncommon

Frequent in

News & Media

50%

Science

36%

Wiki

14%

Less common in

Formal & Business

0%

Academia

0%

Encyclopedias

0%

Ludwig's WRAP-UP

In summary, while the phrase "commented over the" appears in some contexts, including news and media, it is generally considered grammatically incorrect. Ludwig AI indicates that the correct alternative is "commented on". It's best to avoid "commented over the" in formal writing and opt for more grammatically sound options such as ""commented on"", "remarked on", or "observed that" to ensure clarity and credibility. The frequency of this phrase is uncommon, and its usage is spread across news, science and wiki, therefore it's best to avoid it.

More alternative expressions

Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:

Commented on

This is a grammatically correct and widely accepted alternative that directly replaces "over the" with "on".

Remarked on

This alternative suggests a brief statement or observation, emphasizing the act of noticing and commenting.

Observed that

This option implies a more thoughtful or analytical comment, focusing on the content of the observation.

Made a comment about

This is a more verbose but grammatically sound alternative that specifies the type of communication.

Offered commentary on

This suggests a more detailed and insightful analysis, often from an expert.

Expressed an opinion on

This alternative highlights the personal viewpoint or belief being communicated.

Shared thoughts on

This implies a more casual and informal expression of ideas or feelings.

Weighed in on

This suggests adding one's perspective to an existing discussion or debate.

Spoke about

This is a general alternative indicating the act of talking about something.

Addressed the issue of

This option emphasizes the act of dealing with or discussing a particular problem or topic.

FAQs

How can I correctly use a preposition after "commented"?

The correct preposition to use after "commented" when discussing a topic is "on". For instance, you should say "He "commented on" the issue", not "He commented over the issue".

What is a better alternative to "commented over the"?

A more appropriate and grammatically sound alternative to "commented over the" is ""commented on"". This phrasing is widely accepted and ensures clarity in your writing.

Is "commented over the" considered grammatically correct in English?

No, "commented over the" is not considered grammatically correct in standard English. It's preferable to use alternatives like ""commented on"" or rephrase the sentence for clarity.

When should I use "commented on" versus other alternatives?

Use ""commented on"" when you want to indicate that someone made a remark or observation about a specific topic. Other alternatives, such as "remarked on" or "observed that", might be suitable depending on the specific nuance you wish to convey.