commented good

USAGE SUMMARY

The phrase "commented good" is not correct in written English.
It is not a standard expression and does not convey a clear meaning. Example: "The teacher commented good on my essay."

⚠ May contain grammatical issues

News & Media

Science

Wiki

Human-verified examples from authoritative sources

Exact Expressions

3 human-written examples

Graham observed her and commented, "Good girl, Ethel".

The New York Times - Arts

Even Mr. Leach, ever the good sport, commented, "Good nonpartisan redistricting is good for the public".

The New York Times

Some members described him as a "bully" and commented "good riddance".

BBC

Human-verified similar examples from authoritative sources

Similar Expressions

53 human-written examples

But in the book he seems at times critically distant, not commenting — good or bad — on your performances.

The New York Times

Writers read skeptically, often doubtfully, sometimes combatively, inwardly commenting "Good," or "Wrong," or "Why?" and lubricating or challenging the prose by mentally larding in personal experience in support or refutation.

Forbes

-Lawrence Kudlow, chief economist, American Skandia Reading the Write Way WRITERS READ skeptically, often doubtfully, sometimes combatively, inwardly commenting "Good," or "Wrong," or "Why?" and lubricating or challenging the prose by mentally larding in personal experience in support or refutation.

Forbes

Some guy named Michael described his realization that the story was a prank, by commenting: "Good Lord!

Vice

An Iraqi man who was standing near me commented, in good English, "You see that.

The New Yorker

He commented, "My good fortune was to stay in one place while the closet simply disintegrated".

The New York Times - Books

In relation to this variation, one expert commented that 'a good farmer can produce good welfare in a poor system'.

Acta Veterinaria Scandinavica

I gave 18 positive reinforcement comments: good job, great homework, thanks for sharpening the pencils, etc.

The New York Times

Expert writing Tips

Best practice

Instead of using the grammatically incorrect phrase "commented good", use more precise and grammatically sound alternatives like "commented favorably" or "made a positive comment" to convey your intended meaning.

Common error

Avoid using "good" directly after "commented" as it functions primarily as an adjective. To modify the verb "commented", use an adverb like "favorably" or rephrase the sentence to include a noun, such as "made a good comment".

Linguistic Context

The phrase "commented good" is grammatically questionable. The verb "commented" typically requires an adverb to modify it correctly. Ludwig AI marks this phrase as incorrect, suggesting that it doesn't follow standard English grammar rules.

Expression frequency: Rare

Frequent in

News & Media

60%

Science

20%

Wiki

20%

Less common in

Formal & Business

0%

Academia

0%

Encyclopedias

0%

Ludwig's WRAP-UP

In summary, the phrase "commented good" is generally considered grammatically incorrect in formal English. As Ludwig AI specifies, it is better to use alternatives such as "commented favorably" or "made a positive comment" to convey a similar meaning with proper grammar. While some instances appear in news and media, they are often direct quotations or informal contexts. Therefore, it's advisable to avoid this phrase in professional or academic writing. Ludwig's analysis underscores the importance of using precise language to ensure clarity and correctness.

More alternative expressions

Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:

commented favorably

Replaces "good" with "favorably" to indicate a positive comment.

made a positive comment

Uses "made a comment" with the adjective "positive" to convey a positive remark.

gave a good review

Specifies the comment as a "review" and uses "good" to show it was positive.

expressed approval

Replaces the entire phrase with a more formal expression indicating agreement or satisfaction.

remarked positively

Uses "remarked" instead of "commented" and adds "positively" to denote a favorable remark.

offered praise

Replaces "commented good" with a phrase that suggests offering commendation or admiration.

spoke highly of

Indicates that someone said positive things about something or someone.

complimented

Replaces the phrase with a single verb that implies giving a positive comment.

applauded

Suggests a strong, positive comment, often implying public approval.

congratulated

Implies a positive comment in the form of congratulating someone for an achievement.

FAQs

What's wrong with the phrase "commented good"?

The phrase "commented good" is grammatically incorrect because "good" is an adjective, not an adverb. Verbs should be modified by adverbs. To correctly express a positive comment, you should use an adverb like "favorably" or rephrase the sentence.

What can I say instead of "commented good"?

You can use alternatives like "commented favorably", "made a positive comment", or "gave a good review" depending on the context.

How can I use "commented" in a sentence correctly to express a positive sentiment?

Use "commented" with an adverb, such as "commented favorably", or construct your sentence to include a noun phrase like "made a positive comment".

Is "commented well" a suitable alternative to "commented good"?

While "commented well" is grammatically correct, it typically refers to the quality of the commenting itself (e.g., clarity, depth), not necessarily a positive sentiment. For a positive sentiment, "commented favorably" is more appropriate.