I understand that this article was quite stimulating, but that's the style that I have always embraced: commentary should be poignant.
As any provocative commentary should be, this one is contradictory and cacophonous, an echo of the flow of voices throughout the Haggadah, particularly those of the four sons, who lead us into the story by posing four very different questions.
Commentary should be educational or informative rather than inflammatory.
Commentary should be sent to [email protected], with subject line "Green Bank Observatory" by November 25th.
Publications based on personal commentary should be avoided and studies that use non-standard definitions, specific populations or that were conducted before a change in practice (eg, before the adoption of the Good Publication Practice guidelines for communicating company sponsored research in 2003 (GPP) 70 and in 2009 (GPP2) 11) should be described in context.
Much of the response on Twitter reflects the hysteria endemic to instant commentary: Williams should be fired; Williams should throw away his Emmys.
Format Editorial, Focus, Perspective, and Commentary articles should be concise.
Very impressive is "Between Being Born and Dying," a typographic extravaganza that filled every window, corner and column of Lever House in New York with commentaries like "Plenty Should Be Enough".
In the Parisian period Kilwardby wrote mainly logical commentaries, among which should be counted those included in the Course on the Logica Vetus (Lewry 1978): on the Isagoge, Praedicamenta, Perihermeneias, Liber Sex Principiorum, and Liber divisionum Boethii.
His parodies of iconic images by Cindy Sherman, Andreas Gursky, Pipilotti Rist, Andres Serrano, Thomas Ruff, Sherrie Levine, Nan Goldin and other contemporary idols, along with the critical commentary they fuel, should be required viewing for all art-world heavies, particularly critics, curators and collectors.
