challenged to judge

USAGE SUMMARY

The phrase "challenged to judge" is correct and usable in written English.
You can use it when referring to someone being put in a position where they must make a judgment or evaluation, often in a difficult or contentious situation. Example: "In the debate, the moderator was challenged to judge the arguments presented by both sides fairly."

✓ Grammatically correct

News & Media

Wiki

Science

Human-verified examples from authoritative sources

Exact Expressions

3 human-written examples

But last night Reading was challenged to judge whether this was enough, and Reading judged "no".

The Guardian - Music

In the play, Loman reveals his past in scenes from his memory that the audience is challenged to judge for accuracy.

Wikipedia

Interestingly, the absence of logical thinking was most clearly noticeable when the stock-brokers were challenged to judge conclusions that were logically incorrect but were in line with their beliefs.

Plosone

Human-verified similar examples from authoritative sources

Similar Expressions

55 human-written examples

Currently, information on the reliability of these automatically generated databases is not available in the public domain which makes it challenging to judge what these databases can and cannot be used for.

Journal of Cheminformatics

As you frequently hear me preach, it's always a challenge to judge quality in art untested by history, especially when the work is as richly diverse in medium, style and content as that coming out of India since 1947.

Forbes

The only comparable event might be Eyes on Design in Detroit, the event sponsored by the Detroit Institute of Ophthalmology, which also offers a special group of collector cars for the blind and visually challenged to touch and judge.

The New York Times

He pulled a hamstring in October that hampered him for several weeks, and when he felt healthy again last month, Armstead challenged reporters to judge him on how he played during the season's conclusion.

The New York Times - Sports

Ms. Carr said she did not expect her challenge to Judge Bryan to influence judges' decisions.

The New York Times

This month, the Judicial Council of the Sixth Circuit, an administrative body made up of appellate and trial judges, ruled that an ethics challenge to Judge Martin's conduct was moot.

The New York Times

Judge Eismann described his campaign as a challenge to judges who "legislate from the bench".

The New York Times

The scientist himself looks directly out of the picture, as if challenging the viewer to judge whether the pumping should continue, killing the bird, or whether the air should be replaced and the cockatoo saved.

Wikipedia

Expert writing Tips

Best practice

Use "challenged to judge" when you want to emphasize that someone is not only asked to make a judgment, but that there may be difficulties or opposition involved. For example, "The audience was "challenged to judge" whether the performance was a success."

Common error

Avoid using "challenged to judge" when you simply mean 'asked to judge' in a neutral or positive context. "Challenged" implies a degree of difficulty or adversity, so ensure the situation warrants that connotation. Otherwise, consider 'asked', 'invited', or 'tasked'.

Linguistic Context

The phrase "challenged to judge" functions as a verb phrase that positions an individual or group in the role of evaluator. It indicates a call to assess, often implying the presence of difficulty or contention. As seen in Ludwig AI, it reflects an exercise of judgment in complex situations.

Expression frequency: Uncommon

Frequent in

News & Media

33%

Wiki

33%

Science

33%

Less common in

Formal & Business

0%

Encyclopedias

0%

Reference

0%

Ludwig's WRAP-UP

In summary, the phrase "challenged to judge" is a grammatically correct construction used to describe the act of being called upon to make a judgment, often in a situation that presents some level of difficulty or contention. According to Ludwig AI, the phrase is usable in written English, with a neutral tone, adaptable to professional contexts. While "challenged to judge" is not exceedingly common, it appears in various sources like news articles, wikis and scientific publications. When using this phrase, be mindful to capture the nuance of a difficult or complex judgement. Consider alternatives like "asked to evaluate" when a simpler, more neutral tone is desired.

More alternative expressions

Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:

asked to evaluate

Replaces "challenged" with a more neutral term, focusing on the act of assessment.

tasked with assessing

Similar to "asked to evaluate", but emphasizes the responsibility given.

called upon to decide

Highlights the decision-making aspect of the challenge.

invited to critique

Focuses on providing a critical evaluation.

given the responsibility to assess

Emphasizes the accountability in making a judgment.

expected to arbitrate

Suggests a formal role in resolving a dispute.

required to adjudicate

Implies a legal or official judgment.

compelled to render a verdict

Indicates a forced or strong obligation to make a decision.

under pressure to evaluate

Highlights external forces influencing the act of judging.

facing the task of evaluation

Focuses on evaluation but using a different syntactic structure.

FAQs

What does "challenged to judge" mean?

It means someone is called upon to make a judgment or evaluation, often implying that the situation is difficult or contentious.

What can I say instead of "challenged to judge"?

You can use alternatives like "asked to evaluate", "tasked with assessing", or "called upon to decide" depending on the context.

Is it correct to use "challenged to judge" in a formal setting?

Yes, "challenged to judge" can be used in formal settings, especially when emphasizing the difficulty or importance of the judgment. However, consider alternatives like "tasked with assessing" for a more neutral tone.

How does "challenged to judge" differ from "asked to judge"?

"Challenged to judge" implies that there is some difficulty, opposition, or complexity involved in making the judgment, while "asked to judge" is a more neutral request.