but whose consent

USAGE SUMMARY

The phrase "but whose consent" is correct and usable in written English.
It can be used when discussing the need for permission or approval from someone, often in a context where consent is being questioned or emphasized. Example: "The project was initiated without proper authorization, raising concerns about the legality of the actions taken, but whose consent was actually required?"

✓ Grammatically correct

Science

News & Media

Encyclopedias

Human-verified examples from authoritative sources

Exact Expressions

1 human-written examples

But whose consent, and to what?

SEP

Human-verified similar examples from authoritative sources

Similar Expressions

59 human-written examples

Both the African Union and the regional economic bloc have endorsed the idea, but Mali, whose consent is required, has yet to sign off on the idea.

The New York Times

Long enough perhaps for those who are in the majority and can impose their will, but not long enough to gain the consent of those who are opposed and whose consent is essential if we are to remain a united and growing church committed to mission".

The Guardian

Ruth told Ruppert, whose consent he needed.

The New York Times - Sports

Of the 60 organs transplanted in Wales between December and June 2016, half came from people whose consent had been deemed.

The Guardian

Of the 60 organs, 32 came from the 10 people whose consent was presumed under the new set-up.

The Guardian

But each also has a chairman, elected by the inmates, with whom the staff consult closely and without whose consent little seems to happen.

The Guardian

Of the 60 organs transplanted in Wales between December and June, half came from people whose consent had been deemed.

The Guardian

But the humanistic impulses that favored democracy led to questions about whether the state should have the right to kill the citizens upon whose consent government was erected.

The New Yorker

The act strengthened the position of the nobility, whose consent had to be obtained by the granting of privileges.

Encyclopedia Britannica

The locus of power in the English constitution shifted gradually as a result of changes in the groups whose consent the government required in order to be effective.

Britannica

Expert writing Tips

Best practice

When using "but whose consent", ensure the context clearly establishes the contrast or question being raised regarding the necessity or validity of the consent in question.

Common error

Avoid assuming that implied agreement equals explicit consent. Always clarify whose explicit approval is needed, especially in sensitive or formal situations.

Linguistic Context

The phrase "but whose consent" functions as a conjunction phrase introducing a question or a contrasting element. It questions or emphasizes the specific individual or entity from whom consent is required. As Ludwig AI suggests, it is a grammatically correct construction.

Expression frequency: Rare

Frequent in

News & Media

33%

Science

33%

Encyclopedias

33%

Less common in

Wiki

0%

Formal & Business

0%

Social Media

0%

Ludwig's WRAP-UP

In summary, "but whose consent" is a grammatically sound phrase used to question or emphasize the specific source from which agreement is needed. Ludwig AI confirms its correctness, though its relative rarity suggests it's best suited for formal or critical contexts. As shown in the examples, it often appears in news, science and encyclopedia content. When using "but whose consent", ensure the context clearly establishes the contrast or question being raised regarding the necessity or validity of the consent in question, and avoid assuming that implied agreement equals explicit consent.

More alternative expressions

Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:

but whose authorization

Replaces "consent" with "authorization", emphasizing the formal permission aspect.

but whose approval

Substitutes "consent" with "approval", highlighting the act of officially agreeing to something.

but whose permission

Uses "permission" instead of "consent", focusing on the allowance to do something.

but from whom was consent needed

Rephrases the query to focus on the person or entity from which consent was required.

but who needed to agree

Simplifies the phrase, highlighting the necessity of agreement from a specific party.

but whose say was required

Emphasizes the necessity of someone's input or decision.

but whose okay was necessary

Uses "okay" for a more informal tone while conveying the need for approval.

but whose endorsement was crucial

Replaces "consent" with "endorsement", indicating a formal expression of support or approval.

but which party's agreement mattered

Focuses on the significance of a particular party's agreement.

but which authority had to permit it

Shifts the focus to the authoritative entity and their role in permitting something.

FAQs

How can I use "but whose consent" in a sentence?

Use "but whose consent" to question or emphasize the need for permission from a specific party, particularly when there's doubt or debate about its validity or necessity. For instance: "The project was initiated without proper authorization, raising concerns about the legality of the actions taken, but whose consent was actually required?"

What are some alternatives to "but whose consent"?

Alternatives include "but whose approval", "but whose authorization", or "but whose permission". The choice depends on the specific nuance you want to convey regarding formality and authority.

In what situations is it appropriate to use "but whose consent"?

It's suitable in contexts where you're questioning the validity, necessity, or source of consent, often in legal, ethical, or formal discussions. Consider if a more direct phrase like "who needed to agree" might be clearer in informal settings.

What is the difference between "but whose consent" and "but who consented"?

"But whose consent" focuses on the source of the necessary permission. "But who consented" focuses on identifying the individuals who actually gave permission. Use "but whose consent" when the authority granting consent is in question, not merely who gave it.