but nonetheless when

USAGE SUMMARY

The phrase "but nonetheless when" is correct and usable in written English.
It can be used to introduce a contrasting idea or situation that occurs at a specific time. Example: "The weather was terrible, but nonetheless when the sun broke through the clouds, everyone felt a sense of relief."

✓ Grammatically correct

News & Media

Encyclopedias

Science

Human-verified examples from authoritative sources

Exact Expressions

7 human-written examples

My father had heard him preach at chapel and speak in his sacred-studies class, but, nonetheless, when my father knocked on the door he was apprehensive.

The New Yorker

And arguably people were suffering the same way on the way up as they did on the way down, because there were bad sales being recommended, but, nonetheless, when everybody was making so much money nobody was really complaining.

The New Yorker

"I'm strongly atheist by disposition, but nonetheless when this happened, I couldn't help thinking that must be what the hand of God is like, or how it is experienced".

The New Yorker

Fouché's role cannot be denied, but nonetheless, when the majority of the Committee of Public Safety, under pressure from Robespierre, began to criticize the massacres and "dechristianization," Fouché too supported moderation.

Encyclopedia Britannica

That exchange never actually made its way into the final draft of the essay I wrote for Writers Bloc, though it was there in an early version – but nonetheless when I heard the anecdote I understood that it was conversations of this kind that would lie at the heart of articles written by those of us who communicate our understanding – and our confusion – about the world through narrative.

The Guardian - Books

But nonetheless, when I photograph my children, I do it because I love them and want to document their lives.

Huffington Post

Human-verified similar examples from authoritative sources

Similar Expressions

52 human-written examples

Moore improved his footwork as an offensive lineman with the Scottish Claymores, but was cut nonetheless when he returned to Jets training camp.

The New York Times - Sports

But it was a shock nonetheless when, in November 1999, a repossession order arrived.

The Guardian - Lifestyle

It makes Vicky Farrell sad, too, but she gratefully bought a policy nonetheless when AIG introduced it a few weeks ago.

The New York Times

She was frustrated by the new rule but was the guest of honor nonetheless when the Harriet Tubman Home for the Aged celebrated its opening on June 23 , 1908

Wikipedia

Nonetheless, when the fusion RNA, but not ELK4 is silenced, cell proliferation is inhibited in both androgen-dependent and castration-resistant prostate cancer cells.

Cancer Letters

Expert writing Tips

Best practice

Use "but nonetheless when" to introduce a situation that occurred despite a preceding condition or expectation. This emphasizes a sense of something happening regardless of an obstacle or prior circumstance.

Common error

Avoid using "but nonetheless when" when a simple "but when" or "nonetheless when" would suffice. The addition of "nonetheless" should add emphasis, not redundancy. Do not use if a simple chronological order of events is all you intend to convey.

Linguistic Context

The phrase "but nonetheless when" functions as a conjunction phrase, linking two contrasting ideas while specifying a particular time. Ludwig AI confirms its correct usage, showing it introduces a situation occurring despite a preceding condition.

Expression frequency: Uncommon

Frequent in

News & Media

71%

Science

14%

Encyclopedias

14%

Less common in

Formal & Business

0%

Social Media

0%

Wiki

0%

Ludwig's WRAP-UP

In summary, the phrase "but nonetheless when" serves as a conjunction to connect contrasting ideas with a specific timing element. Ludwig AI confirms it as grammatically sound. Although not exceedingly common, "but nonetheless when" is most frequently found in news and media sources, and to a lesser extent in scientific and encyclopedic contexts. When employing this phrase, aim for clarity and emphasis, ensuring it enhances the contrast rather than becoming redundant. Alternatives include "yet still when" and "however even so when", which can provide similar meaning with slightly different emphasis.

More alternative expressions

Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:

but nevertheless when

Replaces "nonetheless" with the stronger synonym "nevertheless", intensifying the contrast.

yet still when

Replaces "nonetheless" with "still", altering the emphasis slightly but retaining the core meaning of contrast and timing.

however even so when

Substitutes "but nonetheless" with "however even so", providing a more emphatic contrast.

but in spite of that when

Replaces "nonetheless" with "in spite of that", making the contrast more explicit.

despite this when

Concise alternative that emphasizes the contrast while maintaining the temporal connection.

even so when

Omits "but", focusing on the contrast introduced by "nonetheless" with a simultaneous event.

still when

Simplifies the phrase by removing "but nonetheless", retaining a sense of contrast linked to time.

but even then when

Emphasizes the timing aspect by including "then", while keeping the contrastive element.

though when

Shortens the phrase to "though when", relying on "though" to convey the contrast.

in any case when

Shifts focus to a sense of proceeding regardless, adding a slightly different nuance.

FAQs

What does "but nonetheless when" mean?

The phrase "but nonetheless when" introduces a situation that occurs despite a preceding condition. It emphasizes that something happened regardless of an earlier circumstance. It's a way to highlight a contrast or unexpected outcome linked to a specific moment.

Can I replace "but nonetheless when" with a simpler phrase?

Yes, you can use alternatives like "yet still when" or "however even so when" depending on the level of emphasis you want to convey. Sometimes "but when" or "nonetheless when" may be sufficient.

Is "but nonetheless when" formal or informal?

The phrase "but nonetheless when" has a neutral to slightly formal tone. It is suitable for both formal and informal contexts, but simpler alternatives may be preferred in very casual settings.

How can I use "but nonetheless when" in a sentence?

For example: "The weather was terrible, but nonetheless when the sun broke through the clouds, everyone felt a sense of relief." This shows that despite the bad weather, a positive event still occurred.