"No case can be proceeded against the Hindujas or the Bofors company in the absence of original documents," the judge said.
It shows that over the past four years black criminals have been less likely to receive police cautions and more likely to have been proceeded against in court, than any other ethnic groups.
In a written judgment, Lord Justice Richards said the challenge was another in a line of cases dealing with the retention of data by the police "after a person has been arrested on suspicion of an offence but has subsequently not been proceeded against, or has been charged and acquitted".
In court, however, he reminded the judiciary they were proceeding against an elected leader.
Thousands of patient lawsuits are proceeding against DePuy in connection with the ASR, and the e-mail is among thousands of company documents gathered by lawyers.
Kobe Bryant's jump shot does not seem to have been harmed by the sexual assault case that is proceeding against him in Eagle, Colo.
"They'd been proceeding against the wrong guy the entire time," she said, "because they hadn't checked the birth certificate".
Three states have revoked the firm's license and another 13 are proceeding against it.
He added: "A very important part about this issue is that those names that were put forward, those people were told no charges could be proceeded with or brought against them.
Falvey filed 17 complaints against the WPBSA but neither these nor other outstanding complaints against Higgins were proceeded with.
Without affiliates outside America, Andersen might be unable to audit large, international firms.Already, a plaintiff lawyer says, work is proceeding on litigation against Andersen because of questionable revenue figures reported by Global Crossing, a bankrupt telecom firm that was its client.
