began joined by

USAGE SUMMARY

The phrase "began joined by" is not correct in written English.
It seems to be a mix of two different phrases and lacks clarity. An example could be: "The project began, joined by several key stakeholders."

⚠ May contain grammatical issues

News & Media

Wiki

Science

Human-verified examples from authoritative sources

Exact Expressions

1 human-written examples

At midday exactly, the aerial bombardment of the palace began, joined by fire from armoured cars surrounding the palace.

The Guardian

Human-verified similar examples from authoritative sources

Similar Expressions

59 human-written examples

So it began joining with venues to formalize standards by which bands could secure bookings.

The New York Times

Merry begins singing, joined by a chorister at the pyramid.

Wikipedia

The two began playing together, joined by the bassist John Lockwood and the drummer Randy Peterson.

The New York Times

They began the season joined by the 6-foot-2, 225-pound Steve Bernier, 23, a rugged fourth-year forward.

The New York Times - Sports

Despite an Orthodox taboo against joint prayer with Catholics, the archbishop immediately began the prayer, joined by his bishops, the pope and his cardinals.

The New York Times

As their son-in-law, Owen C. Pell, later told said, "If you keep the rents in the building lower than they are in the South Bronx, how do you stop the property from running down?" The rent strike began in 1978, joined by nearly half of the Belnord's residents.

The New York Times

In November the ship began working up, joined by the newly completed Hyūga the following month, and both rejoined the 2nd Battleship Division.

Wikipedia

And more than four hours after beginning Paul was joined by the Democrat Wyden.

The Guardian

Soon after his training begun, Henry was joined by another aspiring talent named Dwayne Johnson who was also looking to make his name in professional wrestling.

Independent

WHERE: As Milan Fashion Week begins, Campbell was joined by fellow supermodel Eva Herzigova at the Pirelli Corso Venezia flagship store opening on September 20.

Huffington Post

Expert writing Tips

Best practice

When describing an event that started and then others participated, use "began, joined by" or "started, accompanied by" for clarity.

Common error

Do not combine "began" directly with "joined by" without a comma. The correct structure involves separating the initial action of beginning from the subsequent action of being joined.

Linguistic Context

The phrase "began joined by" attempts to describe an action that commences and is then supplemented by another element. However, the phrasing lacks grammatical correctness without proper punctuation. Ludwig AI confirms this with its assessment that the phrase is incorrect in written English.

Expression frequency: Rare

Frequent in

News & Media

33%

Wiki

33%

Science

34%

Less common in

Encyclopedias

0%

Formal & Business

0%

Reference

0%

Ludwig's WRAP-UP

In summary, the phrase "began joined by" is grammatically incorrect and should be avoided in formal writing. Ludwig AI confirms this assessment. A correct alternative would be "began, joined by", using a comma to separate the two actions. Despite appearing in some news and media sources, the incorrect usage impacts its overall quality and suitability for professional or academic contexts. More appropriate alternatives include phrases like "started accompanied by" or "commenced together with", depending on the intended tone and formality. Remember to separate "began" from "joined by" with a comma for correct grammar. The low frequency of correct examples underscores the importance of careful phrasing.

More alternative expressions

Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:

started accompanied by

Replaces "began" with "started" and "joined by" with "accompanied by", maintaining the core meaning with slightly different wording.

commenced together with

Uses more formal synonyms, replacing "began" with "commenced" and "joined by" with "together with", resulting in a more sophisticated tone.

initiated in conjunction with

Employs highly formal language, replacing "began" with "initiated" and "joined by" with "in conjunction with", suitable for academic or professional contexts.

began in the company of

Substitutes "joined by" with "in the company of", focusing on the presence of others at the beginning of an activity.

started being joined by

Rephrases to emphasize the process of something starting and then gradually being joined by others.

began with the addition of

Focuses on the addition of something or someone after the beginning, rather than simultaneous action.

opened with the inclusion of

Uses "opened" instead of "began" and "inclusion" instead of "joined by", altering the overall tone and emphasis.

began and was followed by

Splits the action into two sequential events: beginning and then being followed by something else.

began, with the subsequent addition of

Highlights that the joining happened after the beginning as a secondary event.

was launched alongside

Replaces "began" and "joined by" with a single phrase emphasizing simultaneous launch or start.

FAQs

How can I correctly use the words "began" and "joined by" in a sentence?

You can say "The meeting began, joined by several new members" or "The concert started, accompanied by a local orchestra". Remember to separate "began" from "joined by" with a comma for correct grammar.

What are some alternatives to the phrase "began joined by"?

Instead of "began joined by", try using "started accompanied by", "commenced together with", or "initiated in conjunction with" depending on the context and formality you are looking for.

Is it grammatically correct to say "began joined by"?

No, the phrase "began joined by" is not grammatically correct. The correct structure would include a comma: "began, joined by".

What's the difference between "began, joined by" and "started with"?

"Began, joined by" implies an initial action followed by others joining, whereas "started with" indicates that the initial action included something or someone from the beginning. For example, "The project began, joined by several key stakeholders", versus "The project started with several key stakeholders".