The contribution, as currently presented, seems to be more appropriate for a more specialized journal.
We cannot recommend the Hafren Power scheme as currently presented to us".
As currently presented, it remains possible that the detected states are subject-specific.
Future research, including the development of scale scores to replace the individual item-level data as currently presented, would be worthwhile.
The data and findings from the RNA-seq experiments should definitely be published, but I'm not sure that they are of sufficient general interest as currently presented.
The effect of birth type was similarly explored in three categories as currently presented, as well as exploring it as a dichotomous variable, that is, vaginal birth compared with caesarean birth, and this did not change the outcome.
Thus, in general, clarification in the figure legends would significantly improve "readability". 1) A major limitation of this work as currently presented is that it is difficult to be definitive about EMT transitions in ES cells.
In part, the processes described here contributed directly to the expansion of the theory from the NPM to the NPT as currently presented (see elsewhere [ 20, 42] for detailed description).
The message of this study is of potential interest for many readers (not only plant pathologists), but there is the danger it will attract little attention as currently presented.
As you can see, both reviewers and the editor found the work putting KI67 in a molecular context very interesting, but we felt that as currently presented, there is not enough phenotype data to really understand what is going on, even though we appreciate that you have already put a lot of effort into phenotypic analysis.
