are extra to

USAGE SUMMARY

The phrase "are extra to" is not standard in written English and may cause confusion.
It could be used in contexts where you want to indicate that something is additional or supplementary to something else, but it is not commonly used. Example: "The costs for the additional services are extra to the base fee."

⚠ May contain grammatical issues

Science

News & Media

Formal & Business

Human-verified similar examples from authoritative sources

Similar Expressions

58 human-written examples

Flights are extra (to-tuscany.com).com

The Guardian - Travel

Perhaps in a preemptive move, Trump used the megaphone that is "Extra" to issue a warning to Maher.

Huffington Post

There are extra ushers to pay, plus everyone needs extra training beforehand.

Independent

"It's going to be extra special to play a major at home," Haas said.

The New York Times - Sports

"We will have to be extra special to get a result.

BBC

These are extra column contributions to peak broadening.

Encyclopedia Britannica

It forces us to be extra sensitive to others, extra compassionate towards others, and to love on others extra hard.

Huffington Post

I just have to be extra attentive to this notion".

The Guardian

And there now seems to be extra incentive to spend whatever cash is out there.

The Guardian

Want to be extra attractive to women?

Huffington Post

"It was extra tough to get to sleep that night".

Huffington Post

Expert writing Tips

Best practice

Avoid using the phrase "are extra to" in formal writing. Opt for clearer and more common alternatives like "in addition to" or "are beyond" to ensure better comprehension.

Common error

A common mistake is assuming "extra" functions like "additional" with "to". "Extra" typically modifies a noun directly (e.g., "extra charges") or is part of other constructions. So instead of saying "the fees are extra to the base price", a better choice is "the fees are in addition to the base price".

Linguistic Context

The phrase "are extra to" attempts to function as a prepositional phrase indicating an addition or supplement. However, Ludwig AI notes it is not standard English. Its function is to denote that something is added to a base or existing element.

Expression frequency: Missing

Frequent in

Science

0%

News & Media

0%

Formal & Business

0%

Less common in

Science

0%

News & Media

0%

Formal & Business

0%

Ludwig's WRAP-UP

In summary, the phrase "are extra to" is not considered standard English and is better replaced by clearer alternatives such as "are in addition to" or ""are beyond"". As Ludwig AI points out, using clearer alternatives ensures better comprehension and avoids grammatical issues. While the intention might be understood, sticking to established phrases is recommended for clarity and correctness.

More alternative expressions

Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:

are additional to

Uses "additional" as a direct synonym for "extra", providing a clearer meaning.

are in addition to

Directly replaces "extra" with "in addition", clarifying the supplementary nature.

are supplementary to

Replaces "extra" with the more formal "supplementary", indicating a supporting role.

are beyond

Indicates that something exceeds a certain limit or expectation.

are above and beyond

Implies exceeding expectations or requirements by a significant margin.

are on top of

Suggests something is added or included with something else.

are inclusive of

Indicates that something is included within a larger set or category.

are further to

Implies adding more to an existing item or situation.

are appended to

Suggests something is attached or added to the end of something else.

are layered onto

Implies something is added as a layer on top of something else, often metaphorically.

FAQs

How can I rephrase "are extra to" in a sentence?

You can replace "are extra to" with phrases like "are in addition to", "are supplementary to", or "are beyond" for clearer communication.

What is a more formal alternative to "are extra to"?

A more formal alternative would be "are supplementary to" or "are additional to". These options convey a sense of something being added in a professional or academic context.

Is "are extra to" grammatically correct?

While the meaning might be understood, "are extra to" is not considered standard or grammatically ideal. It's better to use established phrases to ensure clarity and correctness.

Which is correct, "are extra to" or "are in addition to"?

"are in addition to" is the correct and more commonly used phrase. "Are extra to" sounds awkward and is not generally accepted in formal writing.