Based on the fallacy

USAGE SUMMARY

The phrase "Based on the fallacy" is correct and usable in written English.
It can be used when discussing an argument or reasoning that is founded on a mistaken belief or logical error. Example: "Based on the fallacy that all politicians are corrupt, many voters chose to abstain from the election."

✓ Grammatically correct

News & Media

Science

Human-verified examples from authoritative sources

Exact Expressions

8 human-written examples

It's based on the fallacy of naturalism.

The New Yorker

Franklin goes on to warn: Confessional literature can be wearying because it is so often based on the fallacy that the unvarnished truth is the whole truth and the only truth.

The New Yorker

One teachers' leader, Alberto Lovera, said the approach was based on the fallacy that "the militarization of the supervision of schools is going to resolve all problems" in education.

The New York Times

Finally, the notion that we are still fighting in Afghanistan because the 9/11 attacks originated there is based on the fallacy that our terrorist enemies are so stupid they have remained frozen in place since 2001.

The New York Times

All of this has been based on the fallacy that their lives are more important than YOURS.

Huffington Post

"The rule is based on the fallacy that it is technologically unsafe and economically un-viable to develop the Arctic.

Los Angeles Times

Human-verified similar examples from authoritative sources

Similar Expressions

51 human-written examples

Fears that the third world will steal rich-world output and jobs are based on the old fallacy that an increase in one country's output must be at the expense of another's.

The Economist

All are based on the "economic fallacy" that money is what motivates power in a modern state.

The Guardian - Opinion

They're all based on the most dangerous fallacy known to mankind: Human beings are capable of feeling anything other than the amount of thinking in their heads at any given moment (i.e., the misconception that we feel our circumstances).

Huffington Post

Participants were presented with problems that were based on the classic conjunction-fallacy task (e.g., the "Linda-Problem", see [23]).

Plosone

This view is based on the "lump of labour" fallacy that states there is only so much work to go around.

The Economist

Expert writing Tips

Best practice

When using "based on the fallacy", ensure that you clearly identify the fallacy to strengthen your argument and avoid ambiguity. This makes your critique more precise and persuasive.

Common error

Avoid assuming that because an argument is "based on the fallacy", all aspects of it are invalid. Instead, focus on the specific points affected by the flawed reasoning to maintain a balanced critique.

Linguistic Context

The phrase "based on the fallacy" functions as an adjectival phrase, modifying a noun by indicating that it is founded on a mistaken belief or logical error. It often serves to critique or discredit an argument, idea, or decision.

Expression frequency: Uncommon

Frequent in

News & Media

40%

Science

30%

Formal & Business

10%

Less common in

Wiki

7%

Encyclopedias

7%

Reference

6%

Ludwig's WRAP-UP

In summary, "based on the fallacy" is a grammatically correct phrase used to critique arguments or ideas that are founded on mistaken beliefs or logical errors. Ludwig AI confirms the phrase is usable in written English. While not exceedingly common, it appears most frequently in news and media and scientific contexts. Effective use involves clearly identifying the fallacy to strengthen the critique. Related phrases include "founded on the false premise" and "predicated on the misconception", offering nuanced ways to express similar ideas. When writing, avoid overgeneralizing the scope of the fallacy; focus on specific points affected by the flawed reasoning.

More alternative expressions

Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:

founded on the false premise

Changes the wording to highlight that the base is a demonstrably false premise.

predicated on the misconception

Emphasizes that the base relies on a mistaken understanding or idea.

stemming from the flawed assumption

Indicates that the origin of the idea is a defective or imperfect assumption.

arising from the incorrect belief

Highlights that the emergence of the idea is due to a belief that is not correct.

rooted in the mistaken notion

Suggests that the core of the idea is a notion that is incorrect.

premised on a logical error

Specifies that the argument is built upon a mistake in reasoning.

built upon a faulty premise

Implies a construction or argument that is inherently flawed due to its base.

deriving from an inaccurate understanding

Indicates that the source is an understanding that is not precise or correct.

grounded in a deceptive belief

Highlights that the core belief is misleading or untrue.

hinging on a specious argument

Suggests the argument depends on something that appears correct but is actually false.

FAQs

How can I use "Based on the fallacy" in a sentence?

You can use "Based on the fallacy" to introduce a claim or argument that is rooted in a mistaken belief. For example: "The policy is "based on the fallacy" that increased surveillance reduces crime."

What are some alternatives to "Based on the fallacy"?

Some alternatives to "Based on the fallacy" include phrases like "founded on the false premise", "predicated on the misconception", or "stemming from the flawed assumption", each offering slightly different nuances.

Is it always negative to say something is "Based on the fallacy"?

Yes, saying something is ""based on the fallacy"" is inherently negative because it indicates that the idea or argument is built upon flawed reasoning or a false belief, undermining its validity.

What's the difference between "Based on the fallacy" and "Contains a fallacy"?

"Based on the fallacy" suggests that the entire argument or concept is built upon a false premise, whereas "Contains a fallacy" implies that there might be a flaw in the reasoning within an otherwise sound argument.